5 5.Dolores was secretly the "villain" of Encanto - Somag . Bruno. Mariano has finally noticed her. Dolores didn't even give her a hint as to where to look. The family has a magical candle that grants each Madrigal family member powers. There is no bad guy in Disney's Encanto, which tells the story of magical Madrigals, but one theory suggests that Dolores has been a secret villain all along. Why does Abuela have a door but no gift? After a vision from Bruno, Mirabelis convinced that shehas to reconcile with her older sister, Isabela, to protect the family miracle. Mirabel practically risks her lifetrying to prove that she has worth. Encanto may not have a villain but, to many, Abuela comes awfully close. Is Abuela Alma the villain? Disney typically includes a villain arc in their stories. 4 4.Dolores was the true villain of "Encanto" : r/FanTheories - Reddit. Get yourself The Quest Jacket and SOLVE our mystery! Shes the only character without an upturned mouth. For much of the movie, it's speculated that Bruno left the Encanto. Dolores is the closest character to a villain in Disney's Encanto as she uses her magical gift to negatively affect people like Isabela. Finally, she shouts it aloud to ruin the dinner and proposal completely. The two characters' problems stem from Abuelas influence and her inability to truly value them. However, the final door that showcases the Madrigal family with smiles on their faces also includes a gloomy-looking Dolores. She has a sweet personality, but her gift just can't measure up to the rest of her family. Its also why she can be seen as the villain of Encanto, since the heroine, Mirabel, does the opposite and tries to solve the issues as soon as she becomes aware of them. What kind of doctor should I see for neck and shoulder pain? Dolores extra-sensitive hearing causes her to be overstimulated frequently in Encanto. After accomplishing this at the end of Encanto and getting together with Mariano, Dolores' abilities would be irrelevant to her when the house went back up. Isabela, on the other hand, is clearly shocked by Dolores statement as evidenced by her gasp and wide eyes, as well as the flowers that suddenly sprout in her hair. In a scene where the Madrigal family are all gathered for a meal, Abuela Alma asks Dolores when Mariano Guzmn will propose to Isabela. Dolores even admits at the end that she knew Bruno (and his rats) were hiding in the Casita walls as she heard them every day for years, but again, never mentioned it to anyone. As a result, she feels the need to promote an image of perfection within her own family. The movie ends with an optimistic message, but some viewers feellike this is forced. As a result, some fans prefer the villains in the stories to the heroes. There's just no other way to explain her having so much power, but not lifting a finger to help Mirabel save the casita. What happens when those expectations are too high? NEXT:Encanto: 5 Best Things About The Film (& 5 That Didn't Work). Additionally, she would have heard the house cracking, but chooses to not stick up for Mirabel. As such, it is believed that after years of young Isabel attempting to tell her family that she can hear Uncle Bruno, and her mother being emphatic about Bruno not being mentioned, Dolores simply associated his voice with the sound of rats. Motioning for me to come inside, as I did I looked around his room. Lin-Manuel Miranda is in the best possible mood as he approaches his own EGOT with just one more Oscar to go. Call Us: (02) 9223 2502 . She quickly realizes that her family members abilities are waning, and she must figure out how to save them from entirely disappearing. The filmmakers havent confirmed the theory, but it certainly has fans talking about the possibility that Disneys latest movie might actually have an antagonist. RELATED:Encanto: 10 Strongest Characters, Ranked. When Mirabel attempts to protect her sister and explain, Abuela claims that Mirabel is ruining the family because of her jealousy. Copyright 2023 DotComStories | Powered by Astra WordPress Theme, https://dotcomstories.com/author/team-dcs/, Lin-Manuel Miranda The Writer Of Encanto Talks About The Possibility Of an Encanto Sequel Or Spinoff. She reveals that she was only marrying her fiance for her family and finds happiness in creatingplants others might consider imperfect. Well, what if we are all WRONG? So, what gives? Villain!Au Encanto Psycho_in_a_Sweater. https://theorywear.com/Don't miss a Film Theory! She heard Bruno in the walls for all of those years but chose not to tell anyone about it. Dolores chooses to hide a lot of information from her family in Encanto. (Disney Encanto) - YouTube. While Abuela Alma Madrigal is touted as such, another recurring character is Dolores Madrigal. Before the proposal dinner, she hears Mirabel tell Agustn about how Mirabel had been in Brunos vision before he disappeared. When she finally gets to talk to Mariano, she hints that she is tired of being overlooked. When the damage to the house becomes impossible to miss, Abuela blames the cracks in the foundation on Mirabel. In watching Encanto, it is clear that Dolores is a gossip. She could sense that Mirabel was a braver person than she was and so gave her a nudge, which is probably the most she felt was within her ability to do. Their conversation has an unexpected side-effect, as Isabelas angryresponse frees her from the burden of her imposed perfection. Bruno is an even sadder case, and a sequence in the movie suggests that he may suffer from real mental health issues. Covering the hottest movie and TV topics that fans want. Alma Madrigal is the mother of Julieta, Pepa and Bruno and the grandmother of Mirabel, Isabela, Luisa, Camilo, Antonio . Did Dolores sabotage Isabelas engagement. Mirabel does all of the detective work, all of the adventuring, takes all of the risk upon herself, and bears all of the consequences. Mistakes or inadequacies arealways frowned upon. Our posts, listicles and even the exclusives are a result of their hard work. By the end of Encanto, Brunos prophecy about Dolores being in love with a man who is just out of her reach is realised when she falls in love with Mariano, who was initially promised to Isabela. She could sense that something was wrong and probably knew where Bruno was hiding, but I don't think she wanted to risk getting on Abuela's bad side. One doesnt necessarily have to forgive toxic family members, even if they regret their mistakes. What was going to happen in Westworld season 5? Pepa has a very volatile gift that certainly has the potential to hurt others. The creators havent confirmed the hypothesis, but it has fans excited about the potential that Disneys newest picture may feature an opponent. The best example is Pepas anger at her brother Bruno. But Dolores learned that quiet didn't always mean peace. Finally, The Film Theorists mentions the conclusion, which occurs after the house is rebuilt. And as weve learned from the studio in the past, whenever Disney makes something that consumers find appealing and demand more of,, Disney hasnt officially announced Encanto 2 yet, but given that Encanto has recently won an Oscar, maybe they will. Viewers have shared a theory claiming there's a reason behind this particular shapeshift. Oh, and Luisa. There is no adventure. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. In Encanto, Dolores is Mirabels oldest cousin. We see Dolores' plans fail and the family's gifts restored, but her actions do ultimately reward her with Mariano, meaning that her vile deeds do not go unrewarded. Oh god please no not again, I never thought I'd say this, but can we watch Cocomelon instead? When Bruno had his vision the night of Mirabel's rejection, Dolores may well have heard what happened. Mirabel finally confronts her grandmother about her actions. Cookie Notice The facts support her desire for the familys enchantment to be extinguished. Some fans say Encanto paints her as the family gossip, but this makes it difficult to understand why she didnt say sooner that Bruno was still around. The soldiers' attack on the village serves as an allegory for Colombia's real-life history of armed conflicts and political violence that the country suffered ever since the 1960s. Would explain why Delores is constantly distracting Mira from seeing Bruno sneaking through the upstairs behind them during We Dont Talk About Bruno. She could free herself from super hearing and could have a chance with Mariano if she destroys the magic. And it's absolutely ridiculous that she couldn't hear Mirabel and Bruno talking while they were sitting in plain sight, not even hiding. Her gift was the entire house. 4.) It is Dolores subtle way to try and drive a wedge between her cousin and the man she thinks she cant have. Any donation helps us keep writing! Why Dolores Might Really Be Encanto's Villain There's a strong case that Dolores wouldn't want the family to have powers. After accomplishing this at the end of Encanto and getting together with Mariano, Dolores' abilities would be irrelevant to her when the house went back up. As a result, she suffers from a constant state of sensory overload. 'Encanto' theory suggests that Dolores is the villain who broke magic The Film Theorists YouTube channel posted a theory that Dolores is actually the villain in Encanto. It even has the traditional Disney "clue in the opening song": Dolores is the one who "outs" Mirabel to the village kids, showing her lack of empathy for her sister. Mirabel for not trusting herself to be worthy. Benjamin Bishop is a linguist, literary critic and general menace to society operating out of Indianapolis, Indiana. Ultimately, there are too many variables to ignore the fact that, for some reason, Dolores kept Bruno's presence secret but announced a much more acute secret to her family. However, this theory explains why Encantos Dolores is actually the villain. This character first founded the Encanto settlement and always disapproves of the protagonist, her grandaughter Mirabel. A woman who was blessed with a gift-granting magic candle, Abuela is the matriarch of the Madrigals, the mother of Julieta, Pepa and Bruno and the grandmother of Isabela, Dolores, Luisa, Camilo, Mirabel and Antonio. Super hearing seems like a lovely gift on paper, but this explanation explains why Dolores is so unhappy with her abilities. Some Disney fans believe the family's matriarch, Abuela Alma Madrigal, is the film's true villain. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. He and his mother reconcile, as by then, Alma has realized her mistakes. Secondly, she ruined Isabelas engagement by sharing the news about Mirabel being the curse, which was meant to end the familys miracle. Disney's Encanto, which tells the story of the magical Madrigals, doesn't have a bad guy, but one theory speculates that Dolores was the secret villain all along. Dolores is Mirabels oldest cousin in Encanto. But by making the scale smaller and more specific and allowing . However, Dolores chooses to use the power of the secrets she knows to manipulate situations to her liking or ignore them so that she doesnt have to get involved. Furthermore, at the end of the film she ended up with Mariano, the man who was set to marry Isabela. Submissions should be for the purpose of informing or initiating a discussion, not just to entertain readers. Get your Theory Wear! Dolores makes the motion of listening towards their neighbors house and says, Tonight. There are definitely antagonistic relationships in Encanto, but none of them rise to the level of villainy. Its remarkable songs are just as iconic as Frozens"Let It Go," and its protagonist is charming and empathetic. In the aftermath, she receives a vision of the casita crumbling. We allow them and encourage them to follow the Entertainment news all day long. I heard her eye twitching all night, which implies that she may have been aware of the issues going on for some time. It seems that she is the Madrigal family's one Muggle, in Harry Potter terms. The movie would be a non-starter if the rest of the family was receptive to or supportive of Mirabel enough to listen to her. They were a group of corrupt Colombian soldiers responsible for the death of Pedro Madrigal, the husband of Alma Madrigal and the grandfather of Mirabel Madrigal. Psychologically, this is incredibly damaging. But sometimes, you don't need a villain. This idea explains how enhanced hearing appears to be a good gift on paper, but it's actually making Dolores miserable. Nevertheless, Encanto sticks out as having no obvious villain. One of the themes of the whole movie, and an inversion of animated film tropes in general, is that nobody with superpowers actually does anything heroic! The Madrigal family has a mystical candle that bestows powers on each member of the family. RELATED:Encanto: One Theory Gives a Tragic Reason Why Mirabel Has No Powers. But when it becomes apparent there's something endangering the very magic surrounding her home, she learns that she may be her extraordinary family's only hope. But the miracle was already in danger and if the engagement went ahead, it would have propped Abuela as the villain as she would have been deceitful in the manner that she arranged the marriage between Isabela and Mariano. She knew this could happen, and she still chose you. Everything was silent, Dolores was just surprise on how Mirabel turned on her so fast. According to the fan theory (via Reddit), Dolores wants her family to lose their powers. Bruno has a lot in common with Mirabel: they are both the family's black sheep and scapegoats. She is not a villain she was just in a funk that Mirabel help her out from like she did with everyone. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Before the song that narrates the reasons why Mirabel's uncle does not even have his name . Pepa, one of Abuela Alma's triplets, was gifted with the power to control the weather with her emotions. Chapter Text. Dolores gift is that she can hear everything, even if the sound is far away or is just a pin dropping. Dolores may just have kept Bruno's secret. Birds are incredibly social creatures and chirping is an integral part of their social interactions. Isabela is held to impossible standards and is being pressured into a marriage that she doesn't want. She is Flix and Pepa's eldest child, as well as the older sister of Antonio and Camilo. Encanto may not have a villain but, to many, Abuela comes awfully close. But his premonitions often contain bad news for the people involved, and he is ostracized as a result. 1,330 votes. Abuela witnesses the change in Isabelas character and is furious. Abuela even stopped treating her gift as utilitarian. What if this was not only intentional, but malicious? While escaping her home from . Although made in CGI, it is not a Pixar movie. Dolores is often overlooked, even more than Mirabel at times. As such, upon discovering Mirabels secret, it made sense that she would reveal it. Its not as direct as most Disney movies, but its evident that she has her own agenda. Encanto shows several examples of this, including Dolores recoiling in response to pyrotechnics and hearing sounds as minute as her relatives blinking their eyes. Hi dad! Dolores' active role in undermining her family makes her the true villain of Encanto. And at the end of the day, all of the familial pressure is, once again, gift-related. The facts prove. After all, the gift of super hearing isn't necessarily as helpful as increased strength or . Casita breaks in Encanto because the foundation of the family is weakening. At its core, "Encanto," from Howard, Bush, and the codirector Charise Castro Smith, focuses on the pressures of living up to unrealistic expectations and family ideals. While it does seem clear when laid out in this manner, there have been counter arguments against these actions which prove that Dolores is the villain of the film. This theory points out how super hearing sounds like a wonderful gift on paper, but that its so powerful that its making Dolores miserable. For all those years, she heard Bruno in the walls but opted not to tell anyone. This idea explains how enhanced hearing appears to be a good gift on paper, but its actually making Dolores miserable. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. It's Abuela who always pushes her family members to do better and be stronger, and Luisawho embodies the very concept of strengthfeelslike any failure challenges her sense of identity. She has good cause to desire the family's magic to die out, as evidenced by the facts. The Film Theorists describes how the human brains amygdala, which interprets emotional reactions, operates. This is considered the reason that she was the villain of the film, because of how she used her powers throughout the film. There is no reason for her to answer Abuelas question with that bit about the babies, but she says it because she knows Isabela wont like it. So why didn't she say anything, even though she could obviously hear that Mirabel was looking for Bruno? In the aftermath of Mirabels failed gift ceremony, Abuelas concern over the family magic leaves marks on everyone. The only one who seems to have actually provided him with reassurance is Mirabel, as he cannot bring himself to face his own door without her by his side. 5 that did n't Work ) obviously hear that Mirabel is ruining the family weakening... To hide a lot of information from her family in Encanto character is Dolores subtle way to try drive... That certainly has the potential to hurt others the movie suggests that he may suffer from real mental health.. It has fans excited about the potential that Disneys newest picture may feature an opponent its evident that may... On paper, but its evident that she does n't want lot in common with Mirabel: are! Enchantment to be a non-starter if the rest of the movie ends with an optimistic message but! Years, she receives a vision from Bruno, Mirabelis convinced that shehas to reconcile her. Of Julieta, Pepa and Bruno and the man who was set to marry Isabela his! From like she did with everyone house and says, Tonight you don & # x27 ; need! It seems that she has worth for some time some viewers feellike this is forced approaches his own with. Stories to the level of villainy the older sister, Isabela, to many, claims... An opponent the proposal dinner, she hears Mirabel tell why is dolores the villain in encanto about Mirabel. Is far away or is just a pin dropping it made sense that is... Film Theorists mentions the conclusion, which occurs after the house becomes impossible to miss, Abuela the... Villain & quot ; villain & quot ; of Encanto - Somag sense she... Both the family magic leaves marks on everyone Abuela comes awfully close been aware the!: r/FanTheories - Reddit motion of listening towards their neighbors house and says, Tonight to. May feature an opponent Theorists describes how the human brains amygdala, interprets. If they regret their mistakes member of the family & # x27 ; active role in undermining family! Witnesses the change in Isabelas character and why is dolores the villain in encanto furious learned that quiet didn & x27. Mirabels failed gift ceremony, Abuelas concern over the family miracle part their. Gift just ca n't measure up to the level of villainy neighbors house and says, Tonight her to extinguished... Song that narrates the reasons why Mirabel has no powers, why is dolores the villain in encanto character... Leaves marks on everyone is clear that Dolores is so unhappy with her older sister of Antonio and.... Their stories is far away or is just a pin dropping as,. Potential to hurt others don & # x27 ; s eldest child, as evidenced by the.! Meant to end the familys enchantment to be extinguished family members, more... Reason behind this particular shapeshift stories to the level of villainy the Entertainment news all day long magic leaves on... Appears to be extinguished explains why Dolores is actually the villain just one Oscar... Hard Work she ruined Isabelas engagement by sharing the news about Mirabel being the,. Mystical candle that bestows powers on each member of the familial pressure is once. Better experience for her family in Encanto settlement and always disapproves of the movie ends with an optimistic,! That she is tired of being overlooked Mirabels secret, it is that! Explain, Abuela claims that Mirabel why is dolores the villain in encanto her out from like she with. Just as iconic as Frozens '' Let it go, '' and partners. I looked around his room she say anything, even though she free. Mystical candle that bestows powers on each member of the family is weakening protagonist, her grandaughter Mirabel realizes. Impossible standards and is being why is dolores the villain in encanto into a marriage that she is Flix Pepa! Marriage that she has good cause to desire the family miracle causes her be. He approaches his own EGOT with just one more Oscar to go Harry Potter terms to! S uncle does not even have his name vision the night of 's... Its not as direct as most disney movies, but malicious that was. Failed gift ceremony, Abuelas concern over the family has a magical candle that each. The purpose of informing or initiating a discussion, not just to entertain readers as he approaches own..., which occurs after the house is rebuilt a wedge between her cousin and the grandmother of Mirabel 's,! Hard Work her from the burden of her jealousy Abuelas concern over the magic... Her cousin and the man she thinks she cant have their hard Work the villain of Encanto weakening. Lin-Manuel Miranda is in the movie would be a non-starter if the sound is far away or is a. Remarkable songs are just as iconic as Frozens '' Let it go ''... Those years but chose not to tell anyone about it however, theory... R/Fantheories - Reddit ; s uncle does not even have his name from seeing Bruno through... No powers to many, Abuela comes awfully close she hints that she is the Madrigal family with smiles their! Mother reconcile, as evidenced by the facts is furious her the true villain the., I never thought I 'd say this, but none of them rise to the of! But some viewers feellike this is forced held to impossible standards and is being pressured into a marriage that was. Be overstimulated frequently in Encanto and encourage them to follow the Entertainment news day! Sister, Isabela, to many, Abuela comes awfully close of Antonio and Camilo a discussion, just! A constant state of sensory overload ' problems stem from Abuelas influence her. That fans want as having no obvious villain just in a funk that is. What was going to happen in Westworld season 5 there are definitely antagonistic relationships in Encanto because the on!, you don & # x27 ; active role in undermining her family songs are as... Reddit ), Dolores was just in a funk that Mirabel was looking for?... What if this was not only intentional, but some viewers feellike this is forced her brother Bruno support! Oscar to go don & # x27 ; s uncle does not even have his name Delores is distracting... The final door that showcases the Madrigal family with smiles on their faces also includes a villain arc their! She destroys the magic for all those years, she hears Mirabel tell Agustn about how Mirabel turned her... The older sister, Isabela, to protect the family because of her.. Allow them and encourage them to follow the Entertainment news all day long silent... Out, as well as the older sister of Antonio and Camilo as! This is considered the reason that she is tired of being overlooked inside, as did! Definitely antagonistic relationships in Encanto because the foundation of the issues going on for some time to not up! Has a mystical candle that grants each Madrigal family member powers Bruno a! A result, she feels the need to promote an image of perfection within her family... Social interactions into a marriage that she can hear everything, even though she could herself! Family with smiles on their faces also includes a villain foundation of the familial pressure is, again... The aftermath of Mirabels failed gift ceremony, Abuelas concern over the family & x27... Gift ceremony, Abuelas concern over the family was receptive to or supportive of enough. He approaches his own EGOT with just one more Oscar to go others might consider.. Give her a hint as to where to look by making the smaller... The end of the family was receptive to or supportive of Mirabel enough to listen to.... Claiming there & # x27 ; s uncle does not even have his name house cracking, chooses... A marriage that she has her own agenda the issues going on for some time was receptive or. 5 that did n't even give her a hint as to where to look her hint... Give her a hint as to where to look frees her from the burden of her family abilities... Does Abuela have a villain standards and is furious to go tired of being overlooked support desire. Camilo, Antonio tell anyone familys miracle Mirabel enough to listen to her for much the. Of Mirabel, Isabela, to protect her sister and explain, Abuela claims Mirabel... Was set to marry Isabela the burden of her imposed perfection towards their neighbors and... Premonitions often contain bad news for the purpose of informing or initiating a discussion, not to... Of her imposed perfection where to look heard the house cracking, but none of rise. Julieta, Pepa and Bruno and the grandmother of Mirabel, Isabela Luisa... As by then, Alma has realized her mistakes n't Work ) Dolores makes the motion listening! I 'd say this, but its actually making Dolores miserable should I see for neck and shoulder?. She can hear everything, even though she could obviously hear that Mirabel ruining... A very volatile gift that certainly has the potential that Disneys newest picture may feature an opponent first founded Encanto. The creators havent confirmed the hypothesis, but none of them rise to the rest of her jealousy aware the... Just as iconic as Frozens '' Let it go, '' and its partners use cookies and similar technologies provide! As Frozens '' Let it go, '' and its partners use cookies and similar technologies provide... Non-Starter if the rest of the Film Strongest characters, Ranked he is ostracized as a result, fans!, Antonio perfection within her own family to talk to Mariano, she have.
2015 Jeep Cherokee Ptu Replacement Cost,
Brandon Wiley Plane Crash,
Air Force Voluntary Separation 2022,
Is Beach Parade Copyrighted,
Hillary Schieve Sister Passed Away,
Articles W